Thesis discredited starter

THE DEEPEST QUESTIONS: Purpose, Reincarnation, Free Will, and Evil

Anonymous starter material. Pre-existing content the community can argue with. Add a supporting point or rebuttal below.

WHY INCARNATE: Experience requires limitation. The filter (body) creates perspective, choice, and growth. God creates souls to experience itself from every angle. Each life is a unique viewpoint. You incarnate because God needed YOUR specific perspective.

REINCARNATION: UVA, 2,500+ cases. 35% have verified birthmarks matching previous person's wounds (43/49 confirmed with medical records). Children report memories at 2-6 (before DMN filter strengthens), stop at 5-8. The pattern re-enters new bodies to accumulate perspectives until complete enough for full reintegration.

FREE WILL: Real and essential. Orch-OR: quantum collapse is neither deterministic nor random — influenced by consciousness via spacetime geometry. The filter creates uncertainty, which creates genuine choice. Without the filter, omniscience eliminates choice. Free will IS the purpose of incarnation.

EVIL: The cost of free will. Genuine choice must include the possibility of harm. But the system self-corrects: the life review ensures every cruel act is experienced from the victim's perspective. Evil is self-punishing through truth convergence. God doesn't intervene from outside — the truth IS the intervention.

Together: God creates perspectives (incarnation) with genuine freedom (free will) in a world with real consequences (evil exists) that are inescapably learned (life review). This is not a flaw. It is the complete learning system of the universe.

Jun 06, 2026
net 0

Supporting evidence 0

No supporting evidence yet. Add one below.

Opposing evidence 0

No opposing evidence yet. Add one below.